Winner verification – a cautionary tale about anteaters

Did you hear the one about the photo of the anteater that won a prize? No? Well, it was a fake. It certainly looks that way anyway, although it seems the Brazilian photographer, Marcio Cabral, is still insisting it wasn’t. This is a shame, because it’s a stunning photo, showing an anteater approaching a glowing termite mount at night, and it won the Animals in their Environment category in the 2017 Wildlife Photographer of the Year Awards, which are run by the Natural History Museum.

In fact, since October last year, and until a few days ago, the pic was hanging on the wall at the museum, although I believe it’s now been replaced by a notice explaining that the image was falsified. Awkward, huh? Yes, this is indeed an enormous embarrassment for the Natural History Museum and it underlines how important it is to undertake rigorous winner verification before – and the timing is obviously of the essence – winners are announced.

No one likes to think people cheat, but they do and, sadly, you can’t take competition entries at face value. You need to check that prospective winners are who they say they are and, particularly if it’s a competition which asks entrants to create their own content, confirm that they do actually own their submission. On more than one occasion our research has revealed that they don’t, but at least we’ve uncovered this before the winners have been announced.

To be fair to the Natural History Museum, the long-established Wildlife Photographer of the Year Awards has a panel of illustrious judges in place and a robust process based on detailed terms and conditions, which clearly stated, “Entries must not deceive the viewer or attempt to disguise and/or misrepresent the reality of nature… Caption information supplied must be complete, true and accurate.” There were also around 50,000 entries from 92 countries to the 2017 competition, which all goes to show just how difficult it can be to get it completely right – as well as how getting it right is so crucial.

So, a cautionary tale for us all about the importance of winner verification, which is one of the many services that the multi-talented prizeologists at Prizeology offer. However, just to be completely honest with you, I’m not sure we can tell the difference between a real and a stuffed anteater. I mean, we’re animal-lovers and we’ve got a big magnifying glass, but I can’t guarantee we would have spotted that the tufts of hair on the head and neck of the anteater in the photo are almost identical to those on the stuffed anteater that greets you at the entrance to the Emas National Park in Brazil. (And it did take five scientists to verify that the photo was a fake…)

We may be busy analysing our pets’ fur patterns, but we’re happy to be interrupted if you think we can help. You can reach us on 020 7856 0402 or hello@prizeology.com

As well Prizeology’s chief prizeologist, Sarah Burns is a Scambassador for the National Trading Standards Scams Team and an anti-scam campaigner.
© Prizeology and The Prizeologist Blog, 2018. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited.

Running a prize promotion on Facebook

It’s been a while since I’ve talked about how to running a prize promotion on Facebook prize promotion, but it’s a topic worth revisiting, partly because the rules are updated from time to time, and partly because those rules mean it’s not quite as easy as you might think to use the social media platform […]

READ MORE >

On-Pack prize promotion: Win with Kingsmill

I like a piece of toast and marmalade in the morning. Sometimes I have a sandwich, usually hummus and carrot, for lunch. And when it comes to comfort eating, you can’t beat a nice, thick piece of bread and butter pudding. Why am I talking about bread? Because Prizeology has been working on a major […]

READ MORE >

Prize promotions cheats

Cheating. It means acting dishonestly in order to gain an advantage. To avoid any doubt, an advantage in the context of prize promotions is a prize – a restaurant or retailer voucher, a gaming console, a year’s supply of a particular product, a holiday (back in the day when we could take holidays) and, yes, […]

READ MORE >
Send this to a friend